At Reis-Nichols Jewelers, we offer the best engagement ring selection in the Indianapolis metro area. Our high-quality designs coupled with our wide selection of diamonds allow you to create the perfect ring. Get started by browsing below or schedule an appointment with one of our Diamond Experts ready to work with you to craft the perfect ring.
Indianapolis's Favorite Engagement Ring Destination
Engagement Rings
Engagement Rings
Alternating Baguette & Round Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$3,315
Center Stone Sold Separately
East West Set Oval Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,665
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,280
Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET Classic Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$2,010
Center Stone Sold Separately
Round Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,975
Center Stone Sold Separately
PRECISION SET New Aire Cathedral Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$2,380
Center Stone Sold Separately
Fancy Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring Setting
$1,535
Center Stone Sold Separately
Twisted Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,175
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,680
Center Stone Sold Separately
Pear Shape Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,940
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$1,540
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,115
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,835
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$4,390
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$3,780
Center Stone Sold Separately
Vintage Style Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,420
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
$2,310
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,575
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,715
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$5,020
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Halo Engagement Ring
$3,540
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,920
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,985
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,575
Center Stone Sold Separately
Woven Diamond Engagement Ring
$5,050
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,075
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,405
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$5,345
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$4,410
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,225
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$6,120
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,165
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,320
Center Stone Sold Separately
Braided Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,295
Center Stone Sold Separately
Classic Diamond Engagement Ring Setting
$2,040
Center Stone Sold Separately
Diamond Engagement Ring
$3,115
Center Stone Sold Separately
Custom Design Your Ring
Your dream ring can become a reality in the hands of our award-winning artisans. Our in-house jewelers work with you one one-on-one to custom design and create a ring to your specifications.
Our Guarantees & Services
Choosing your engagement ring from our stores means a lot! Learn about our complimentary services and lifetime guarantees that come with your purchase.
Bridal & Diamond Guide
Learn about what makes a diamond unique and how the 4 C's create a diamond's value. Also, discover your preferred style and your favorite diamond shapes.