You've heard Reis-Nichols Jewelers is your one carat diamond destination, now let us tell you why!

When you shop with us, you'll find...

  • The LARGEST selection of one carat diamonds in more shapes, colors and clarity
    than you'll find anywhere else.
  • HUNDREDS of settings made just for a one carat diamond.
  • PRICES that can't be beat - not in stores - not even online!

Browse our incredible selection of engagement rings to get started.
Visit one of our Indy-area locations to find your perfect ring!

Selection - Settings - Price
Reis-Nichols is your One Carat Diamond Destination!

Not looking for a one carat diamond? No problem!
We carry diamonds in every size,shape and price range.

How to choose the right diamond.

Carat Weight & Price *

We say our pricing can't be beat, but doesn't everyone? The diamond pricing listed below is for near colorless and SI quality and are the minimum standard quality of diamonds we carry in our stores every day. All are lab certified. We're happy to help you find the exact diamond you want, at a price that simply can't be beat!

.50 ct. $1,295 .75 ct. $2,595 .90 ct. $3,995 1.00 ct. $4,995 1.25 ct. $6,495 1.50 ct. $9,495 2.00 ct. $15,495

*Pricing for a round brilliant cut diamond.
Pricing varies based on cut, color and clarity of each diamond.

“I stopped at several stores and looked online for the best diamond at the best price. I was afraid I couldn’t afford a Reis-Nichols diamond, but then I made one last stop at your Keystone store. I’m so glad I did. You had the diamond I wanted at the perfect price, and she loves it!”

– Ryan, Indianapolis

“We were really ‘wowed’ by the selection of engagement rings and diamonds we found at Reis-Nichols. Nowhere else in town did we find so many options, and such great designers! We got exactly what she wanted, and couldn’t be happier. Thank you!”

– Jack & Tiffany, Greenwood

“Tim was amazing to work with. He was patient, honest and conscious of my budget. His customer service and support was awesome. Thank you, Tim, for making my experience so positive. Most importantly, she said yes!”

– Jason, Fishers

Set up a personal appointment • Ask us anything • Or just come on in and see us
Bridal Manager
Fashion Mall Commons
Email Tim
Bridal Manager
Greenwood Centre
Email Rachel
Special Offer
Have lunch on us! Just email Tim or Rachel to make an appointment
& receive a free lunch at McAlister’s.