Skip to content
Extended Store Hours Now on Thursday 10AM-7PM | Free 2-Day Shipping on Orders $500+

Choose Your Diamond

Engagement is an exciting moment for you and your significant other. Finding your perfect diamond engagement ring should be just as exciting. Here at Reis-Nichols, we not only carry a superior selection to choose from, but we will also find the diamond you are looking for at the right price. No matter what is important to you, we will have your perfect fit.

The Reis-Nichols Diamond Difference


It is always best to have a few shape choices in mind and to not get set on only one. Some diamond shapes may not complement the ring style you are looking for and different stones will have different pricing—so keep your options open!


Next, consider the 4Cs of Diamond Quality (cut, carat weight, color, and clarity). A bigger center stone does not always mean it holds higher value. All 4Cs contribute to a diamond’s value. That is why when shopping for your diamond, it is important to have an idea of which of the four are most important to you.


Diamond Carat diagram

Bigger is better, right? It depends.

Carat is the “C” you are probably most familiar with. If you already have a carat weight in mind, great! Unsure? Visit us and take a look, of course, we carry diamonds in all sizes. A one-carat diamond is the most popular, and you will find the largest selection of one-carat diamonds at Reis-Nichols, at prices that can’t be beat.

Get Started

Ultimately, it is up to you to decide what you are looking for in your diamond. Our expert diamond associates are here to answer all your questions and to help you navigate your diamond selection journey. Not only can they show you a wide variety of loose diamonds to choose from, but they’ll provide you the best diamond shopping experience Indianapolis has to offer. You can learn more about our diamonds and lifetime guarantees when you purchase your ring from Reis-Nichols Jewelers.