Engagement Rings Meant for You, Chosen for a Lifetime

Proudly Serving the Greater Indianapolis Area for Generations

Our Story: A Legacy Since 1919

Since 1919, Reis-Nichols Jewelers has been a trusted name in fine jewelry in Indianapolis. What began as a small jewelry manufacturing operation in the Circle City has grown into a multi-generational legacy rooted in craftsmanship, integrity, and a passion for celebrating life’s most meaningful moments.

Today, we are proud to create engagement rings that honor every love story, each piece thoughtfully designed with timeless elegance and crafted to the highest standards of quality. Whether you are drawn to classic styles or modern designs, our collection reflects over a century of expertise and dedication.


Start your engagement journey with confidence. Visit us in store for a personalized experience tailored to you, or explore our collections online at your convenience.

START BROWSING STYLES

BUILD YOUR RING ONLINE

SCHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT

Your Ring, Our Promise to You

At Reis-Nichols, your ring is more than jewelry. It is a symbol of your love and a promise for the future. For over a century, our legacy of craftsmanship has been shaped by more than 450 years of combined experience, allowing our expert jewelers to create bridal pieces as unique as your story.

 

From discovering your ideal style and diamond shape to guiding you through every step, we make the journey simple, personal, and enjoyable. Whether you visit us in store, explore online, or schedule a personalized appointment, our team is here to serve couples across the Indianapolis metro with exceptional care, expertise, and attention to detail.

 

Every ring we create is crafted by skilled hands and backed by a lifetime guarantee because your forever deserves nothing less.

OUR DIAMOND DIFFERENCE

Your Ring, Our Promise to You

At Reis-Nichols, your ring is more than jewelry. It is a symbol of your love and a promise for the future. For over a century, our legacy of craftsmanship has been shaped by more than 450 years of combined experience, allowing our expert jewelers to create bridal pieces as unique as your story.

 

From discovering your ideal style and diamond shape to guiding you through every step, we make the journey simple, personal, and enjoyable. Whether you visit us in store, explore online, or schedule a personalized appointment, our team is here to serve couples across the Indianapolis metro with exceptional care, expertise, and attention to detail.

 

Every ring we create is crafted by skilled hands and backed by a lifetime guarantee because your forever deserves nothing less.

OUR DIAMOND DIFFERENCE

Your Start to Finding the Perfect Ring

  • RING STYLES

  • DIAMOND SHAPES

  • BUILD YOUR RING ONLINE

Start Shopping by Engagement Ring Style

Start Shopping by Diamond Shape

Create Your Engagement Ring

ONLINE ENGAGEMENT RING BUILDER

Craft the perfect ring online. Our custom builder allows you to select your setting and handpick your diamond, giving you full control from inspiration to purchase.

BUILD YOUR RING ONLINE

ONE-OF-A-KIND CREATIONS, 
YOUR VISION, OUR CRAFT

CUSTOM ENGAGEMENT RINGS

CONSULTATION FORM

OUR PORTFOLIO

LEARN MORE

Custom Engagement Rings in Indianapolis, Designed Just for You

Your love story is one of a kind—your engagement ring should be too. At Reis-Nichols Jewelers, we specialize in custom engagement rings designed and crafted in-house, right here in Indianapolis. Whether you’re inspired by a photo torn from a magazine, a family heirloom, or a simple sketch on a napkin, our expert designers can bring your vision to life.

Custom Doesn’t Mean More Expensive

Many people are surprised to learn that a custom engagement ring doesn’t have to cost more than a traditional setting. Because our custom design process is handled entirely in house, we’re able to create exceptional, personalized engagement rings while maintaining outstanding value. You’ll have full control over the design, materials, and budget—without compromising on craftsmanship or beauty.

Award-Winning Jewelers, Crafted in Indiana

Our reputation as one of the best custom engagement ring jewelers in Indiana is built on decades of expertise and award-winning craftsmanship. From hand-selecting diamonds to perfecting every detail of the setting, our Indianapolis-based jewelers ensure your ring is made to last a lifetime. Every custom engagement ring is designed with precision, care, and a deep understanding of what makes your story unique.

A Personalized Custom Design Experience

Our custom jewelry design process is collaborative and stress-free. You’ll work one-on-one with our experienced designers to refine every detail—from stone shape and metal choice to setting style and finishing touches. The result is a bespoke engagement ring that reflects your style, your story, and your future together.

Start Your Custom Engagement Ring Journey

If you’re looking for custom engagement rings in Indianapolis, Reis-Nichols Jewelers offers unmatched design expertise, in-house craftsmanship, and personalized service. Discover why so many couples across Indiana trust us to create the ring that marks the beginning of forever.

CONSULTATION FORM

OUR PORTFOLIO

LEARN MORE

Custom Engagement Rings in Indianapolis, Designed Just for You

Your love story is one of a kind—your engagement ring should be too. At Reis-Nichols Jewelers, we specialize in custom engagement rings designed and crafted in-house, right here in Indianapolis. Whether you’re inspired by a photo torn from a magazine, a family heirloom, or a simple sketch on a napkin, our expert designers can bring your vision to life.

Custom Doesn’t Mean More Expensive

Many people are surprised to learn that a custom engagement ring doesn’t have to cost more than a traditional setting. Because our custom design process is handled entirely in house, we’re able to create exceptional, personalized engagement rings while maintaining outstanding value. You’ll have full control over the design, materials, and budget—without compromising on craftsmanship or beauty.

Award-Winning Jewelers, Crafted in Indiana

Our reputation as one of the best custom engagement ring jewelers in Indiana is built on decades of expertise and award-winning craftsmanship. From hand-selecting diamonds to perfecting every detail of the setting, our Indianapolis-based jewelers ensure your ring is made to last a lifetime. Every custom engagement ring is designed with precision, care, and a deep understanding of what makes your story unique.

A Personalized Custom Design Experience

Our custom jewelry design process is collaborative and stress-free. You’ll work one-on-one with our experienced designers to refine every detail—from stone shape and metal choice to setting style and finishing touches. The result is a bespoke engagement ring that reflects your style, your story, and your future together.

Start Your Custom Engagement Ring Journey

If you’re looking for custom engagement rings in Indianapolis, Reis-Nichols Jewelers offers unmatched design expertise, in-house craftsmanship, and personalized service. Discover why so many couples across Indiana trust us to create the ring that marks the beginning of forever.

Personalized Service for Every Client

Finding the perfect engagement ring is deeply personal, and your experience should be too. With over 450 years of combined expertise, our bridal experts are here to guide you with thoughtful advice, genuine care, and attention to every detail that matters most to you.


Whether you are just beginning to explore styles or ready to choose the one, we will meet you where you are, answering questions, offering insight, and helping you feel confident every step of the way.


Schedule an appointment for one on one guidance from a dedicated bridal expert at our Greenwood or Indianapolis locations.

SCHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT

Not Sure Where to Begin? Start by Understanding Diamonds & the 4 C’s

Choosing the right ring begins with understanding what truly matters. Explore our Diamond and Bridal Guide to learn the 4 C’s, including cut, color, clarity, and carat, and select with confidence.

BRIDAL & DIAMOND GUIDE

More on Engagement & Diamonds

Have a Question?

Connect with a Reis-Nichols team member at your convenience for further assistance.

CONTACT US